Politicians and Burglars

Fear and frustration regarding America plague more than half the country. Families regularly cut back to accomodate shrinking incomes. The current Congress and Administration, like recent predecessors, never consider that as an option. When things get tough for the small people, that is just another excuse for the political elite to increase their spending and their power.

Whether they politicians get the funds by increasing the tax burden on citizens or they print money matters little. Higher taxes means less income available to purchase goods. Printing money means higher prices of goods, effectively reducing the amount of goods that can be purchased. The net is virtually the same either way — citizens get poorer and government gets bigger.

As people increasingly face reduced standards of living and connect the dots to this sophisticated form of political theft their opinions of politicians shrinks. The current distrust and disgust toward politicians has never been so intense. A recent survey showed them registering at the very bottom against other occupations:

Clearly the public does not trust its leaders. The political class increasingly does not care. Surely they would prefer to be more popular, but not if it infringed on their own objectives. Their comfort is more important than conforming to the wishes of constituents. In a very real sense, we may have attained the wrong side of the dichotomy that Thomas Jefferson described:

When the people fear their government, there is tyranny; when the government fears the people, there is liberty.

People may disagree that we have reached the tyranny stage yet.  But there likely would be close to universal agreement that we no longer meet the second part of Mr. Jefferson’s dichotomy. Does anyone believe that government fears the people? If so, how do they explain the deliberate continuance of behavior that has produced such dislike and distrust? When government ignores the wishes of the people it is clear government has no fear of the people.

For those who argue there is no tyranny, let them define some third classification which Mr. Jefferson did not provide for. Would it be some intermediate political purgatory, sort of a waiting stage for tyranny?

Politicians are held in lower regard than any other occupation, even the ones most maligned. But perhaps the comparisons are unfair. Increasingly people are viewing political behavior as corrupt and criminal. Perhaps the proper comparison would be to measure politicians against illegitimate occupations.

What if politicians were polled against criminal activities like burglars or drug dealers or bank robbers? Would political activities out poll truly criminal activities? It certainly would represent an interesting poll. From an economist’s point of view, there is case to be made that politicians would lose.

Let’s take a look, for example, at a burglar. Fortunately few of us have experienced a burglary. If you have, it is a scary and demeaning event, even if you did not encounter the perpetrator. Your property was violated. The place you felt most secure, your house or apartment, will never feel the same again. You will always worry about it recurring. Will he come back? What if you are home this time? Will you be safe there or should you relocate? There are serious emotional issues cannot be quantified.

Presumably you have also been damaged with loss of possessions. These can be quantified and likely replaced. This part of the experience is generally the least harmful. It costs you money that you shouldn’t have to spend, but it is a one-time event. The monetary damages may be large or small but they are unlikely to exceed a few months of your earnings.

Now contrast that experience with the cost of supporting politicians. It is estimated that the total take to support governments at all levels exceeds 40% of GDP. For you as an individual, it means that about five months of your income is taken from you every year. Unlike the burglar, this take occurs again and again for as long as you work. It continues when you have no income in the form of property, sales and other taxes. Finally it stops with death and death taxes.

To be fair, there is value provided for the taxes. Roads are maintained (sort of), police exist to investigate crimes after the fact, a court system mediates disputes, schools are funded, etc. etc. It is not unreasonable to say that none of these functions are performed efficiently or effectively. That is, private enterprise would provide them better and at lower cost. But that is not the real theft that government represents. You are paying multiples for the value of the services you receive. Think about how much you could buy with an extra five months of income. Do you think you are getting your money’s worth by giving this money up for the services received? Even those who believe in the necessity of an expansive government have trouble answering in the affirmative.

Whatever the difference is between the value of services you receive and the amount you pay in total taxes has been coerced from you in the same manner that the burglar entered into a transaction with you that you did not agree to. When viewed in these terms, I would rate the politician as more harmful than the burglar.

Perhaps politicians would rate more favorably against pedophiles, rapists and murderers.


Related Posts


  1. I must voice serious disagreement with the premise that our government is not, “conforming to the wishes of its constituents”. If that be true, how could one explain the fact that over 90%+ of the incumbents are returned to power for another term? Reid and Pelosi come immediately to mind as examples.
    In Christianity it is taught that we must make as our first desire God’s will to be done in our lives. It was recorded as part of Jesus’ prayer the evening before He was tortured and crucified. “Not my will but Thine…”. We the People have forgotten that our first desire as regards our politics is that the Constitution be scrupuliously followed. Instead we have substituted “my will” or “my benefits” or “my entitlements” rather than living in constant awareness that it is God’s gift of Liberty that is more important than life itself.
    The author proposes a poll rating politcians in comparison to, “pedophiles, rapists and murderers”. I submit an even more relevant poll would show the Founders’ low opinion of our current electorate as compared to those who pledged their lives, their fortunes and sacred honor in the struggle for the greatest opportunity in history to form a government in which the people werre invested with power and the government would be their servant.
    “Honor, justice and humanity forbid us tamely to surrender that freedom which we received from our gallant ancestors and which our innocent posterity have a right to receive from us. We cannot endure the infamy and guilt of resigning succeeding generations to that wretchedness which inevitably awaits them if we basely entail hereditary bondage on them.” Jefferson

    1. How could it be? people are busy watching “American Karioke” and paying no attention to what is really heppening. When Nazi Pelosi stands up and ou right lies, the media blesses her and endorses her! There is NO COUNTER VOICE unless one SEEKS IT OUT !!! The truth is perpetually hidden and the lies are persistently spread and repeated. The REAL question is how does ANYONE escape the liberal stranglehold to come to sites like this to discover the truth! It’s a miracle frankly.

Post a Comment